Potentiality of Cybernetics for Socio-Political Conflict Resolution
A Proposed Model for SAARC Member Countries
By
Dr. Subodh Chandra Garai
Former Principal
Baruipur College
(at south of Kolkata)
(PIN – 743610)
Residence:
Laskarpur (Purbapara)
(in between Garia and Narendrapur)
PIN – 700153
[Presented at Internatioal Seminar Held on 10-11 Nov., 2016 at BANKURA UNIVERSITY
Bankura, W. Bengal, India]
Abstract
The party or leader in power is traditionally being considered completely honest, intellectually sound and efficient whereas the party or leader who was recently defeated is considered disgustingly dishonest, dull and inefficient – in fact, is this cent percent correct? The ruling party and its followers (i) try to oppress or dominate opponents to create a master-slave relationship even applying brutal force and hence violence compelling surrender (with latent grievance creating future possibility of ventilating it in terms of retaliation/ resistance which again calls for force and hence violence) – these situations naturally encourage maintenance/ hiring of private army and illegal arms-ammunitions and (ii) show vindictive attitudes towards opponents and extraordinary sympathy towards party colleagues or members of their factions and hence misusing the constitutional authority fostering own party objectives rather than safeguarding and promoting national or social objectives. Should these situations prevail in future too? The ruling party and its followers try to deceive the followers of other party with regard to carrier opportunities whereas followers of same party/ group get extra favour. Is it not possible to alter the situation? In modern days, resources are becoming scarce due to their multiple uses and also due to increase in demand for increase of population and standard of living. But those resources have also parallel use to boost political violence; again, such violence destroys/ disfigures even antiques and heritages or destroys/ delays developmental projects. Should this socio-political environment prevail in future too? Almost all political parties proposed as well as opposed Ombudsman system for controlling administrative excesses or misuse of public authority/ power, e.g., system of control by Lokpal or Lokayukth. Is it not possible to devise/ inoculate a system of control within and by the (political) system itself, following the principle of cybernetics in mechanics as well as in living things or internal check system in business management or accounting/ auditing, for good governance?
Introduction
To begin with, we are narrating some contemporary socio-political situations/ issues here which should be addressed in the next section and, subsequently, for appropriate socio-political conflict resolution, some reasonable prescriptions can be given:
1. Hero-Zero Situation:
The party or leader in power is traditionally being considered as full-proof and completely honest, intellectually sound and efficient whereas the party or leader who was recently defeated is considered disgustingly dishonest, dull and inefficient. In fact, is this cent percent correct?
Is it not at all possible to continue playing positive/ constructive role by the defeated party or leader to supplement the role of ruling party or leader, for social stability or development?
2. Situation of Political-Violence:
The ruling party and its followers (capturing power) try to oppress or dominate opponents to create a master-slave relationship even applying brutal force and hence violence that deserves surrender of the opponents (with latent grievance for the time being creating future possibility of ventilating it in terms of retaliation or resistance which again calls for force and hence violence) – these situations naturally encourage maintenance of private army (or utilizing hired miscreants) and illegal arms and ammunitions like jaminders of earlier days. As a consequence, to mitigate or control violence, excessive police force equipped with modern technologically updated instruments as well as methods are being required now that elicits heavy public expenditures and, as an inevitable consequence, inadequate attention towards maintenance of normal law and order situation and public tranquility.
Should these situations prevail in future too?
3. Biased Attention by Ruling Party-Leader towards Opponents’ Grievances:
The ruling party and its followers (occupying responsible position in public administration) show vindictive attitudes towards opponents and extraordinary sympathy towards party colleagues or members of their factions and hence misusing the constitutional power/ authority fostering own party objectives rather than safeguarding and promoting national or social objectives for the welfare of general public at large.
Should these situations prevail in future too?
4. Biased Attention by Ruling Party-Leader towards Opponents’ Opportunities:
The ruling party and its followers (occupying responsible position in public) try to deceive the followers of other party with regard to carrier opportunities, e.g., education, business or employment potentiality and the like, whereas followers of same party/ group get extra favour in those matters.
Is it not possible to alter the situation or at least to alleviate the situational disparity between negative favour against opponents’ person and positive favour for own person of the ruler?
5. Sub-Optimal Utilisation of Resources towards Public Welfare and Sustainable Development due to Application of Those Resources for Political Violence:
In modern days, resources (physical, human and cultural) are gradually becoming scarce due to their multiplicity of uses and due to increase of demand for population increase as well as increase of standard of living. But those resources have also parallel use to boost political violence; again, such violence destroys/ disfigures even antiques, memoirs and heritages or destroys/ delays developmental projects.
Should this socio-political environment prevail in future too?
6. Controlling Excesses of Ruler by External Body/ Agency, e.g., Ombudsman, Attracts Resistance/ Unacceptance by Political Leaders:
Almost all political parties proposed as well as opposed Ombudsman system for controlling administrative excesses or misuse of public authority/ power, e.g., system of control by Lokpal or Lokayukth.
Is it not possible to devise/ inoculate a system of control within and by the (political) system itself, following the principle of cybernetics in mechanics as well as in living things or internal check system in business management system or, more specifically, accounting/ auditing, for the sake of better future governance?
Are bionic principles not at all applicable in political system with democratic flavour?
In the next section, we shall attempt to survey the existing literature on the applications of cybernetic principles and processes as well as role of media, for successful performance of a democratic system in this electronic age of globalised socio-economic perspective. In the subsequent section, we shall strive to propose the model of a self-reliant political system, with an expectation of a better socio-political environment in future.
Survey of Existing Literature
The word cybernetics1 was first used by Athenian philosopher Plato (427 – 347 B. C., the student of Socrates and the teacher of Aristotle) in the context of “the study of self-governance” by him in his last work (unfinished at the time of his death)2 The Laws to signify the governance of people.
On the concept of ‘cybernetics’, we may first take a notice on the view3 expressed in Encyclopædia Britannica, viz.,
Cybernetics is associated with models in which a monitor compares4 what is happening to a system at various sampling times with some standard of what should be happening, and a controller adjusts the system’s behaviour accordingly.
Pictorially a Cybernetic Model with, say, Controller (A) & Monitor (B)
The term cybernetics comes from the ancient Greek word kybernetikos (“good at steering”), referring to the art of the helmsman. In the first half of the 19th century, the French physicist André-Marie Ampère5, in his classification of the sciences1, suggested that the still nonexistent science of the control of governments be called cybernetics. The term was soon forgotten, however, and it was not used again until the American mathematician Norbert Wiener published his book Cybernetics: Or Control and Communication in the Animal and the Machine in 1948.
However, some interesting and noteworthy definitions of Cybernetics are reproduced from Wikipedia (the free encyclopedia, hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation, a non-profit organization that also hosts a range of other projects) here as
Wiener (1948) defined cybernetics6 in 1948 as “the scientific study of control and communication in the animal and the machine.”
“Science concerned with the study of systems of any nature which are capable of receiving, storing and processing information so as to use it for control.” — Andrey Nikolaevich Kolmogorov (25 April 1903 – 20 October 1987).
“A way of thinking about ways of thinking of which it is one.” — Laurance D. Larry Richards, one past president (1986-1988) of the American Society for Cybernetics and also president (1988-1999) of the American Society for Engineering Management; he was a member of the editorial board for the journals Cybernetic (1987-1989) and Systems Research (1988-1994) and a consulting editor (1992-1994) for Cybernetics and Human Knowing.
“The science and art of the understanding of understanding.” — Rodney E. Donaldson, another past president (1992-1993) of the American Society for Cybernetics.
“Cybernetics is the study of systems and processes that interact with themselves and produce themselves from themselves”7— Louis H. Kauffman, another past president (2005-2008) of the American Society for Cybernetics; in topology he introduced and developed the ‘bracket polynomial’ and ‘Kauffman polynomial’ — the knot theory and also found relationship between cybernetics and knots8.
Systems theory in political science9 is a highly abstract, partly holistic view of politics, influenced by cybernetics10. The adaptation of system theory to political science was first conceived by David Easton in 1953, as reported by Wikipedia:
In simple terms, Easton’s behavioral11 approach to politics, proposed that a political system could be seen as a delimited (i.e., all political systems have precise boundaries) and fluid (changing) system of steps in decision making. Greatly simplifying his model:
Step 1. Changes in the social or physical environment surrounding a political system produce “demands” and “supports” for action or the status quo directed as “inputs” towards the political system, through political behavior.
Step 2. These demands and supporting groups stimulate competition in a political system, leading to decisions or “outputs” directed at some aspect of the surrounding social or physical environment.
Step 3. After a decision or output is made (e.g., a specific policy), it interacts with its environment, and if it produces change in the environment, there are “outcomes.”
Step 4. When a new policy interacts with its environment, outcomes may generate new demands or supports and groups in support or against the policy (“feedback”) or a new policy on some related matter.
Step 5. Feedback, leads back to Step 1, forming a never-ending cycle.
If the system functions as described, then we have a “stable political system”. If the system breaks down, then we have a “dysfunctional political system”.
Easton aspired to make politics a science that is, working with highly abstract models that described the regularities of patterns and processes in political life in general. In his view, the highest level of abstraction could make scientific generalizations about politics possible. In sum, politics should be seen as a whole, not as a collection of different problems to be solved.
His main model was driven by an organic view of politics, as if it were a living object. His theory is a statement of what makes political systems adapt and survive. He describes politics in a constant flux, thereby rejecting the idea of “equilibrium”, so prevalent in some other political theories. Moreover, he rejects the idea that politics could be examined by looking at different levels of analysis. His abstractions could account for any group and demand at any given time. That is, interest group theory and elite theory can be subsumed in political systems analysis.
His theory was and is highly influential in the pluralist tradition in political science.
In the earlier cited source (viz., Wikipedia), it is mentioned that in artificial intelligence, computer vision, control systems, conversation theory, interactions of actors theory, learning organization, robotics and also in biology, computer science, engineering, management12, mathematics, psychology, sociology13, education, art and earth system science the principles and processes of cybernetics are applied. Cybernetics is also applied in complexity science (complex adaptive system, complex systems and complexity theory) and biomechatronics.
In political science14, Project Cybersyn15 attempted to introduce a cybernetically controlled economy during the early 1970s. In the 1980s, according to Harries-Jones (1988) “unlike its predecessor, the new cybernetics concerns itself with the interaction of autonomous political actors and subgroups, and the practical and reflexive consciousness of the subjects who produce and reproduce the structure of a political community. A dominant consideration is that of recursiveness, or self-reference of political action both with regards to the expression of political consciousness and with the ways in which systems build upon themselves”. This opinion was passed by him as a critic of the work by Dobuzinskis (1987).
Thus, in case of every system, for its proper functioning to survive/ sustain, the application of cybernetic principles and processes is desirable, aiming at self-control by the system itself through sub-system of governor(s) and feedback mechanism (of output information) to control input or to adjust the system itself or the internal process to attain/ maintain a normative level of output/ outcome. And hence, on universal applicability of cybernetics, the following two assertions16 worth noting:
“Of course, the field of cybernetics is much broader, embracing all steering processes, and its principal aim is to identify general principles of steering and control.” – Piotrowski (2012), in the 1st paragraph.
“That is, I want the label ‘cybernetics’ to attract people who have an interest in both the subject and practice of conversation, and of creating the ‘new’ out of this form of dynamic interaction, irrespective of whether their interests are in electronics, life, society, or mind, and whether they come from science, art, or politics.” – Richards (1999), under sub-topic ‘Introduction’ of the topic ‘Definitions of Cybernetics’.
Also, the similar assertion by Kolmogorov (cited earlier from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybernetics#Definitions) is noteworthy enough. Regarding the appropriateness of cybernetics in political science, “the French physicist and mathematician André-Marie Ampère first coined the word ‘cybernetique’ in his 1834 essay ‘Essaisur la philosophie des sciences’ to describe the science of civil government” – retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybernetics#Definitions, under Etymology.
Regarding sustainability of democracy and application of cybernetics, feedback information and control systems and the like, in this ‘cyber age’ or ‘knowledge age’, views expressed in Laszlo (1984, it conceptualized human societies as natural systems satisfying four basic system criteria: Ordered wholeness; negative feedback deviation-reducing capability; positive feedback deviation-amplifying, self-evolving capacity; and dual-structural adaptation to sub- as well as supra-systems) is noteworthy. And also the views in Birrer (1999, Frans A. J. Birrer is from Mathematics, Computer Science & Society, Leiden, The Netherlands), worth mentioning as
An examination of critique on early systems and cybernetics approaches leads to specific tasks for second order cybernetics, particularly with respect to the role and responsibility of the systems analyst (second order observer). The use of scientific advice should preserve as much as possible the principles of participation and democracy. This implies a modified view of the status of expert statements, as well as the necessity of certain checks and balances. The latter leads to interesting and relevant questions for cybernetics. Two mechanisms are identified that can make the role of research distorting rather than enlightening the problems at hand. Environmental issues constitute a prominent field where the limitations of classical approaches as well as the opportunities for second order cybernetics can be demonstrated. Improving on overall sustainability depends on democracy and participation. Checks and balances guarding the role of expertise are essential.
Some other relevant and thought-provoking research works in this line are Tumbull (1994, it identifies four types of governance mechanisms from which the theory of the firm becomes a special case of a general theory of social construction — the design criteria are based on the closed-loop feedback information and control systems found in all living things), Espinosa et al. (2005, this paper synthesizes the somewhat different insights of Stafford Beer and the ‘Santiago School of Cognition’, reports on a real-world initiative that sought to instantiate governance as a phenomenon constituted by the governed and technological developments of the ‘knowledge age’ are proposed as supporting such democratic initiatives), Leonard (2006, recommending the proper application of cybernetic control principles to governance and democracy considering momentum, requisite variety and scale), Vedel (2006, discussed on three ages of ‘electronic democracy’, the first age of which began in the 1950s with the emergence of cybernetics sciences under Norbert Wiener), Espinosa (2007, from a cybernetic perspective, explains why the development of structural conditions for democratic involvement is a necessary condition for the effective implementation of evolutionary development at the societal level) and Andrew (2008, the CYBCOM17 discussion list, on possible revision of the definition and nomenclature of cybernetics, is reviewed and discussed, as are also certain proposals for enhancement of existing systems of parliamentary democracy, indicated by e-democracy).
Concerning socio-political conflict resolution applying systems model, cybernetics and all that, (besides others) research works are found in Knight et al. (1971), Chestnut (1986, Harold Chestnut was the first president of the International Federation of Automatic Control), Chestnut et al. (1990), Byrne (2003, reference to cybernetic process is given in Introduction, Table 1 and ‘Use Objective Criteria’ section), Hipel (2009), Ramsbotham et al. (2011), Lent (2013), Zaraté et al. (2014, papers on Proceedings of the Joint International Conference of the INFORMS GDN Section and the EURO Working Group of Decision Systems Support) and Zhou et al. (2015).
Mass media (especially print media) is popularly called the fourth estate or fourth branch of government, hence, for successful performance of a democratic system, role of responsible media18 is certainly important, at least to confirm or refute the veracity of information published or supplied to the public institutions as well as general public at large by the executives in public administration (including political leaders at different levels). As to the contribution of mass media to modern democracies, a few of the recent research works19 are Kriesi (2012), Kriesi et al. (2013, in the last monograph considering monographs of all authors, the first author Kriesi assessed the state of democracy given the challenges of globalization and mediatization), Müller (2014a and 2014b, examines the contribution of mass media to modern democracies, in comparative perspective) and Humprecht (2016).
From the foregoing review of literature, it is quite alluring to suggest that the future generation students should learn the subjects like Set Theory, Logic, Cybernetics (including Computer Applications), and certainly, Statistics as well as Journalism with Political Science; as an analogy, the related subjects considered in case of Philosophy are Logic, Ethics, Psychology etc.
Design of the Proposed Model of Self-Reliant Political System
In this section, we are in a position to strive for proposing and designing the model of self-reliant political system, with an expectation of a better socio-political environment and, certainly, to get rid of all the six odd situations/ issues raised in the introductory section.
To start with, let us consider a (apparently observed) process of gaining power which is contemplated and exhibited in Figure 1 (a movement to the right indicates a later state and a sub-set of left mentioned items). In this figure, in case of religious leaders, some miracles are canvassed by a very few number of closely related disciples to get blind confidence hence support of a large section of public – but their case is beyond our consideration here, since no scientific justification supports their footing and hence we should concentrate our attention in acquisition of power20 in a political system, to dominate a considerably large section of public, i.e., followers.
Before prescription of a detailed design of the proposed model, let us now consider a feedback diagram, similar to one shown at the end of end note 7 and also earlier, which is depicted here as a flow chart in Figure 2:
In Figure 2, (i) Pi, Pe and Po will represent three activities, viz., input(s), execution and output(s) respectively (the subscripts – i for input, e for execution and o for output), of the party or leader in power, P, (ii) M will represent opposition party representative or leader and (iii) C will represent a constitutionally authorized independent person holding quasi-judicial authority to get feedback from M; C will scrutinize the feedback information or signal and do the needful as indicated in the diagram, applying prudence and judgement – the resulting set up then should be called a self-reliant21 political system with a feedback and correction mechanism. Role, authority and ambit of M will also be constitutionally determined and M will only be authorised to collect information periodically (say, weekly or monthly) and may take help of reliable and responsible media, general public or non-governmental organizations (including semi-governmental organizations, like Pollution Control Board, Human Rights Commission etc.). And C should suggest correction for significantly negative deviation from the norm (a broad-band socially determined standard or the pre-determined government policy), desirably in quantitative term, i.e., in money unit, time unit or any other fundamental or derived unit of measurement (objectively defined) – if the policy parameter is qualitative in nature that also should be precisely defined and properly published. Pi’s are the inputs of prevailing or hired nature and they are the resources of any kind, i.e., physical, human or cultural types – tangible or intangible (i.e., service or right). Whereas Po’s are outputs of the nature of commodity, service or infrastructure (even right in rem or in persona of public, relief, equitable treatment etc.). Normally, C should have no commanding authority22 to force correction but should be authorized to refer the exceptional case23 (i.e., highly intolerable negative deviation) to a traditional court of law with appropriate jurisdiction and hence such court may enforce suggested or appropriate corrections. Thus, on the condition that there is complete absence of collusion24 or connivance between two or more parties (i.e., P, M and C), the system is highly expected to produce better result. Hence, for each level (i.e., local self-government, municipal body/authority, state or central level) same structure can be adopted. The person C may act in common for more than one units (e.g., more than one gram panchayats) or say, only one such person for the whole panchayat samity. And M’s may be different persons for local level and state level with different quality or experience (to be selected by opposition). All the persons in the three categories should be honoured by remunerating from the national exchequer, for their valued service to the nation. If required, appropriate personal safety and other facility may also be guaranteed by the state, in favour of both M and C. Hence, oppositions may be considered as the fifth estate or fifth branch of the government.
The following advantages are highly expected from the implementation of the model described in this section (in the preceding paragraph):
- To the Oppositions: They
- get importance to a certain extent;
- being remunerated, get opportunity to work for gainful engagement – thus necessity of anti-defection law will no more be strongly justified;
- provide continuous service to society, for its welfare or early warning to avoid social wastage/ loss — thus chance of regaining social acceptance/ confidence;
- get information about ruling party’s activities so as to prepare them by adopting good deeds of the ruling party, in principle – to prepare themselves to be more deserving to general public in future and
- help the quasi-judicial authority by supplying relevant information in time – thus getting satisfaction and confidence.
- To the Ruling Party: From the system,
- indirectly getting help by the leaders of the ruling party, they have an opening to rectify and hence, to optimize social welfare in exchange of minimum cost and hazard;
- almost timely relevant and vital bits of information in terms of feedback may give a chance to modify the actions or even the plan/ policy;
- valued source of information being bestowed upon – in case of error, fraud or conspiracy committed by a follower, it provides opportunity to take timely and appropriate remedial measure;
- the provision for appreciation (in favour of good deeds) by the quasi-judicial authority will boost the moral strength of the ruling party leaders – that will maintain or even enhance the confidence of the followers including supporters from general public and
- the leaders in power get a guarantee that if defeated in the next election, they will not be totally ousted from future opportunities or importance rather will get due respect as well as gainful engagement – such a guarantee will minimize misuse of constitutional authority or growth of favouritism and hence corruption.
- To the Society at Large:
- A congenial, compromising and cooperative attitude of ruling and opposition parties can be able to restore public tranquility and hence social atmosphere becoming friendly academic pursuit, business as well as industrial activity and also all sphere of life will be more simple as well as encouraging and stimulating enough. It is also expected that number of litigations will come down.
- Quality goods, services, facilities, opportunities, reliefs, treatments and infrastructures will be available to the peace loving citizens for reasonable public expenditure (by the state, individuals or organizations) and hence that will sufficiently compensate even surpass the additional expenses (to be borne by the state for administering the proposed model).
- Politics having been a respectable profession, many honest, socialized and knowledgeable as well as proficient persons will be keen to join and practice the profession.
- Above all, the resultant reputation of the concerned unit (i.e., gram panchayat, panchayatsamity, zilaparishad, municipal body/authority, state or country, as the case may be) will make proud not only the ruling party or its members but also all inhabitants of the concerned administrative unit.
- Lastly, a recent trend in world politics as well as in our country is that politics is no more considered as a merely social service (free of cost) rather it is clearly visioned as an independent profession (for earning at least livelihood)25 and hence implementation of the proposed model will advance that view recognizing politics as a full-fledged profession – at least in a sovereign modern country like ours.
Conclusions
In this paper, initially, some contemporary socio-political odd situations/ issues were reported. After review of existing literature on applicability of cybernetic principles and processes (that are successfully operating in living things as well as in some machines) and also role of responsible media for efficient running of a democratic system, applying the principles and processes of cybernetics, a self-reliant model of socio-political system in modification of the system in operation is devised where role of oppositions is respected and formally incorporated in the main political system. It is highly expected that the resultant socio-political system (after such incorporation of the proposed model) will mitigate the odd situations mentioned earlier and also it will be operationally cost saving and quality improving system that will be beneficial to public in general as well as to the party in power and the oppositions; as a byproduct of the resultant system, politics will be honoured by professional recognition.
End Notes
1. Retrieved from http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Cybernetics#History (under the subtopic ‘The roots of cybernetic theory’).
Historically, application of cybernetic principle and process was first traced in the water clock or clepsydra (“water thief”), invented by Ctesibius or Ktesibios or Tesibius (Greek: Κτησίβιος; fl. 285–222 BC) was a Greek inventor and mathematician in Alexandria, Ptolemaic Egypt. Based on a tank which poured water into a reservoir before using it to run the mechanism, it used a cone-shaped float to monitor the level of the water in its reservoir and adjust the rate of flow of the water accordingly to maintain (restricting overflow also) a constant level of water in the reservoir. – Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybernetics#Roots_of_cybernetic_theory.
2. Retrieved from http://www.iep.utm.edu/plato/#SH7f.
3. Retrieved from https://www.britannica.com/topic/cybernetics.
4. This process is known as feedback or homeostasis, retrieved from http://kids.britannica.com/comptons/article-325313/homeostasis, for details of feedback (positive and negative). The relationship between cybernetics and homeostasis as well as relevance of homeostasis for human being, a society or a machine is better described at http://everything2.com/title/Cybernetic+theory+and+homeostasis.
5. André-Marie Ampère, (born Jan. 22, 1775, Lyon, France — died June 10, 1836, Marseille) French physicist who founded and named the science of electrodynamics, now known as electromagnetism. His name endures in everyday life in the ampere, the unit for measuring electric current. – Retrieved from https://www.britannica.com/biography/Andre-Marie-Ampere.
6. In this context, Wiener (1950) in the section ‘CYBERNETICS IN HISTORY’ explained the word ‘Cybernetics’ and its origin from the Greek word kubernẽtẽs which means “steersman” as well as “governor”.
Heinz von Foerster (German spelling: Heinz von Förster; November 13, 1911, Vienna – October 2, 2002, Pescadero, California) was an Austrian American scientist combining physics and philosophy, and widely attributed as the originator of Second-order cybernetics (i.e., cybernetics of cybernetics). He was twice a Guggenheim fellow (1956–57 and 1963–64) and also was a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1980. He is well known for his 1960 Doomsday equation (Foerster et al., 1960) formula published in Science predicting future population growth. – Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heinz_von_Foerster.
The Third-order cybernetics is seen as the relationship which exists between the observers in a network. A cognitive approach that aims at analyzing the link among relational properties, communication, and organizational change processes, is developed by Johannessen and Hauan (1994). The Fourth-order cybernetics is understood as concerned with how multiple realities are shaped by, and impinge upon, power relationships within society — retrieved from http://kairos.laetusinpraesens.org/thirdord_0_h_9 and also Božičnik and Mulej (2011). Even the existence of Fifth-order cybernetics is referred by Novikov (2016), published on 10 January, 2016 – Table 1.1 on ‘Different types of cybernetics’ in page no.12 of the book also deserves special attention of the future researchers on cybernetics and its applications.
7. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybernetics#Etymology, the section on ‘Etymology’. A simple feedback pictorial model (actual figure is available direct from https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ed/Ideal_feedback_model.svg) is also reproduced here from that section as
8. Cybernetic Math Cyber{K}nots, retrieved from http://homepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/.
9. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_theory_in_political_science.
10. Vide Easton (1953), Easton (1965a) and Easton (1965b) – David Easton (June 24, 1917 – July 19, 1914) was a Canadian (Toronto, Ontario)-born American political scientist and was, amongst other prominent positions, president (1968–1969) of the American Political Science Association and also served as chairman (1972) of the Committee on Scientific Information Exchange of the American Political Science Association.
11. Again, as per Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavior), behavior (or behaviour) is the range of actions and mannerisms made by individuals, organisms, systems, or artificial entities in conjunction with themselves or their environment, which includes the other systems or organisms around as well as the (inanimate) physical environment. It is the response of the system or organism to various stimuli or inputs, whether internal or external, conscious or subconscious, overt or covert, and voluntary or involuntary.
12. The applications of cybernetics in management science can be found (besides others) in Ghosal (1980), Hanika (1982), Morgan (2006, identified eight images or metaphors of organisations, viz., as Machines, as Organism, as Brains, as Cultures, as Political Systems, as Psychic Prisons, as Flux and Transformation and as Instruments of Dominations – discussed on the nature of each metaphor and its role in understanding organization and management), Zannetos (2015) and Malik (2016). Cybernetics is also very relevant to Nudge Theory – a powerful change-management methodology which emerged in the 2000s, retrieved from http://www.businessballs.com/cybernetics.htm (under the 2nd sub-heading ‘the 1st law of cybernetics’) and http://www.businessballs.com/nudge-theory.htm.
13. The applications of cybernetics in sociology can be found (besides others) in Geyer et al. (2001) and Zouwen (2001) and McClelland and Fararo (2006).
14. Other applications of cybernetics in political science can be found in Deutsch (1966, more discussion on this is done by Langdon Winner, 1969, as a review article, retrieved from http://jstor.org/stable/41035143), Bryen (1971), Ghosal (1980), Corning (1996), Yolles (2003), Corning (2005, in Chapters 6 & 7 of Part I and Chapter 16 of Part IV – two special terms, viz., ‘Bioeconomics’ and ‘Thermoeconomics’ were introduced in this book), Morgan (2006, in Part II of the book, during discussion on some images or metaphors of organisations— in chapter 6 of that part, details on interest, conflict, and power of organizations as political systems are discussed), Espinosa and Leonard (2006), Cashore and Howlett (2007) and Rhodes and Hart (2014).
15. Project Cybersyn was a Chilean project from 1971–1973 during the presidency of Salvador Allende aimed at constructing a distributed decision support system to aid in the management of the national economy. The project consisted of four modules: an economic simulator, custom software to check factory performance, an operations room, and a national network of telex machines that were linked to one mainframe computer. The principal architect of the system was British operations research scientist Anthony Stafford Beer (25 September 1926 – 23 August 2002, a consultant and professor, best known as management cybernetician) – retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Cybersyn.
Other discussions on Project Cybersyn are also available in Medina (2006) and Medina (2011).
16. As an interesting metaphor regarding importance of lever, similar assertion/ claim by Archimedes may be cited here from Tzetzes (12th Century A. D.) as
he [Archimedes] used to say, in the Doric speech of Syracuse: ‘Give me a place to stand and with a lever I will move the whole world.’
17. The Research Program, the Cybernetics Communication Listserve or CYBCOM, maintains a discussion list for over one hundred participants around the world. The topics being discussed are cybernetics and systems theory and their applications. CYBCOM Home Page is https://hermes.gwu.edu/cgi-bin/wa?A0=CYBCOM and the e-mail ID is CYBCOM@HERMES.GWU.EDU. Web address of Cybernetics Discussion Group for November 2023 is https://hermes.gwu.edu/cgi-bin/wa?A1=ind2311&L=CYBCOM.
18. The recent online e-article Praveen (2014) may also be consulted, in this context.
19. All the cited books in that paragraph are amongst ten authored or edited monographs of the series Challenges to Democracy in the 21st Century which in turn edited by Hanspeter Kriesi, published by Palgrave Macmillan (a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited), U. K., during 2012 – 2016, with the forewords (retrieved from http://www.palgrave.com/in/series/14889) as
Democracy faces substantial challenges as we move into the 21st Century. The West faces malaise; multi-level governance structures pose democratic challenges; and the path of democratization rarely runs smoothly. This series examines democracy across the full range of these contemporary conditions. It publishes innovative research on established democracies, democratizing politics and democracy in multi-level governance structures. The series seeks to break down artificial divisions between different disciplines, by simultaneously drawing on political communication, comparative politics, international relations, political theory, and political economy.
An important characteristic of this series is that significant number of these monographs emphasized the role of mass media to boost up democracy in the 21st Century. Two relevant online-articles of the London School of Economics and Political Science, concerning Eurocrisis in the Press, Müller (2014a and 2014b) and Radice (2016) are also cited here.
20. In this context, it is worthy of a mention that Yolles (2003) rightly opined, “Politics used power and power processes to shape structures, manipulate information, and influence the way that people behave. The concept of centripetal politics used by Ionescu in his discussion of the changes over the last century to society is applied to organisations and their political processes. The outcome suggests the possibility of a political map that has the potential to explain organizational behaviour.” – retrieved from http://emeraldinsight.com/doi/abs/10.1108/03684920310493242.
From https://movetoamend.org/toolkit/guide-power-mapping, about power mapping, we can know:
In order to effect social change, an advocate needs to be aware of the political and social power structures in play. A power map is a useful visual tool for figuring out who you need to influence, how to influence them, and who can do the influencing in order to reach a specific goal. This guide will help you create your own power map for your area.
Before you Power Map
Make sure you’re well versed in Move to Amend’s national strategy and familiar with the Pledge to Amend Campaign’s goals. Information about Pledge to Amend Campaign can be found here: https://movetoamend.org/pledge-amend
Steps to Power Mapping
1. Determine your Target
Which elected officials are you going to focus on? Who is the key decision maker here? Map around a person or institution who can solve a problem. For Pledge to Amend, it’s going to be an elected official.
2. Map Influence of your Target
Once you’ve identified who you want to target, you can start writing down people or institutions who you think might be able to influence him/her, and their other associations. An easy way to get started is to look at your elected official’s major donors. From there you can plot out influential constituents and other groups he/she may have interacted with.
Find out everything you can about your elected officials, including the committees they serve on, their past voting records, their individual ideologies, political connections, campaign contributors, which staff people they rely on the most, what their hobbies are, etc. Use these to connect them to other actors in the field.
Some other ideas for mapping your target:
• Past coworkers
• Family
• Major donors
• Voting record and committees your target works on
• Media outlets that favor your target
• Other personal relationships
You don’t want to rule out anything right off the bat. So even if you know you don’t want to approach a certain group your target is connected to, map it anyway. You never know where it might lead.
It’s also helpful to map out any organization (and people related to these organizations) that might work on this issue as well. For example, if your goal is to get better conditions for workers, it’s a good idea to put down labor unions, even if they’re not directly connected to your target.
Connect these in a visual map.
3. Determine Relational Power Lines
Many of the groups you map out will have connections to each other, not just to your elected official. You may notice that one group or actor connects to many other influencers; this is called a “node of power.” Even if a node of power doesn’t connect directly to your target, it may still be useful depending on who it’s connected to and how many connections it has.
4. Target Priority Relationships
Analyze the map. You want to focus on the actors with the most connections or that are most significant to your target. Highlight these nodes of power and start thinking of a strategy to approach them. It may be helpful to your strategizing process to grow your map by expanding on these nodes. Don’t worry if it gets a little messy!
5. Draw a grid to plot influence and helpfulness
To figure out which of your target’s influencers can be the most helpful, plot them on a grid like the one below: This is an easy way to assess who will be most supportive, and influential.
6. Make a Plan
Now that you have a map of your target’s relationships, you can move on to the rest of the strategizing process.
Note: ‘Move to Amend’ is an US forum of citizens and institutions/ organisations with a demand of amendment of American constitution to delimit the dominance of corporate world.
21. The proposed model is not claimed as a novel one, rather attempts in this line to some extent are taken in different times and by different countries, e.g., chairmanship of Public Accounts Committee is offered to the leader of opposition party in India. Though ‘public interest litigation’ is introduced in our country with some flavor in this direction, it is not strictly application of cybernetic principles or processes or its variants (as any person even other than opposition member can initiate this lawsuit initially and directly to a court, an external agency).
22. But C may issue ‘show cause’ notice for not timely providing information to M or for non-implementing earlier suggestions.
23. Frequent non-implementing suggestions, irregularity of supplying information, ignoring/ delaying answer to ‘show cause’ notice may be considered as exceptional cases (except in case of military importance, of the state) too.
According to strict flow chart parlance, left-end corner of the diamond (i.e., the rhombus shape expressing conditional) in the chart should remain blank – therefore, another diamond can be used in the ‘Yes’ branch of the conditional C (hence renaming it, Cl), the second conditional may be named as Cu, Cl will then be lower level controller who will send the significantly negative deviation to higher level controller Cu, Cu in turn will ultimately judge negative deviation into low-high category and highly negative deviation should be referred to higher authority (preferably to an appropriate law court, as mentioned earlier). Hence, for other category of negative deviation suggestion for correction should be fed back to the system.
24. The same condition is required for effectiveness of an ‘internal check system’ in management, more specifically, in accounting/ auditing. On the efficacy of internal check system, an auditor can take resort to test checking to some extent.
25. Our Election Commission, for this reason perhaps, provides cost of election. If in the globalised and liberalized economic environment, education is considered as a tradable product by universities or professional institutes, why not politics be considered as a gainful and prestigious profession?
References
Andrew, Alex M. (2008), “Cybernetics and e-democracy”, Kybernetes, Vol.37, No.7, pp.1066 – 1068.
Birrer, Frans A. J. (1999), “Sustainability, democracy, and sociocybernetics”, Kybernetes, Vol.28, No.6/7, pp.810 – 820.
Božičnik, Stane and Matjaž Mulej (2011), “A new – 4th order cybernetics and sustainable future”, Kybernetes, Vol.40, No.5/6 , pp.670-684.
Bryen, Stephen David (1971), The Application of Cybernetic Analysis to the Study of International Politics, Springer, Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague (Netherlands).
Byrne, Sean (2003), “Linking Theory to Practice: How Cognitive Psychology Informs the Collaborative Problem-solving Process for Third Parties”, International Journal of Peace Studies, Vol.8, No.2, pp.29–43, http://www.jstor.org/stable/41852900.
Cashore, Benjamin and Michael Howlett (2007), “Punctuating Which Equilibrium? Understanding Thermostatic Polity Dynamics in Pacific Northwest Forestry”, American Journal of Political Science, Vol.51, No.3, July, 2007, pp.532–551.
Chestnut, Harold edited (1986), Contributions of Technology to International Conflict Resolution, Proceedings of the International Federation of Automatic Control, Pergamon Press (of IFAC), Oxford, New York, Beijing, Frankfurt, Sāo Paulo, Sydney, Tokyo and Toronto.
Chestnut, Harold, P. Kopacek and T. Vamos edited (1990), Contributions of Technology to International Conflict Resolution, Proceedings of the International Federation of Automatic Control Workshop at Budapest, Hungary, 5-8 June 1989, No.1 of the series, Pergamon Press (of IFAC), Oxford, New York, Beijing, Frankfurt, Sāo Paulo, Sydney, Tokyo and Toronto.
Corning, Peter Andrew (1996), “Synergy, Cybernetics and the Evolution of Politics”, International Political Science Review / Revue internationale de science politique, Vol.17, No.1, January 1996, pp.91-119.
Corning, Peter Andrew (2005), Holistic Darwinism: Synergy, Cybernetics, and the Bioeconomics of Evolution, University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London.
Deutsch, Karl W. (1966), The Nerves of Government: Models of Political Communication and Control, Free Press, New York, pp.xxxvi, 316.
Dobuzinskis, Laurent (1987), The Self-Organizing Polity: An Epistemological Analysis of Political Life, Westview Press, ISBN 0813304342.
Easton, David (1953), The Political System: An Inquiry into the State of Political Science, Alfred A. Knopf, New York, pp.xiii, 320.
Easton, David (1965a), A Framework for Political Analysis, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N. J., pp.xvi, 143.
Easton, David (1965b), A Systems Analysis of Political Life, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, pp.xvi, 507.
Espinosa, Angela, R. Harnden and J. Walker (2005), “Cybernetics and Participation: From Theory to Practice”, Systemic Practice and Action Research, Vol.17, No.6, p.573.
Espinosa, Angela and A. Leonard edited (2006), Cybernetics and Public Administration: Special Issue, Emerald Group Publishing Ltd. (Kybernetes, Vol.35, No.1/2) also available at http://www.emeraldinsight.com/doi/10.1108/k.2006.06735aaa.002.
Espinosa, Angela and Roger Harnden (2007), “Complexity Management, Democracy and Social Consciousness: Challenges for an Evolutionary Learning Society”, Systemic Practice and Action Research, October 2007, Vol.20, No.5, pp.401–412.
Forester, Heinz von, Patricia M. Mora and Lawrence W. Amiot (1960), “Doomsday: Friday, 13 November, A. D. 2026”, Science, 04 November 1960, Vol.132, No.3436, pp.1291-1295.
Geyer, Felix R. and Johannes van der Zouwen edited (2001), Sociocybernetics: Complexity, Autopoiesis, and Observation of Social Systems, Contributions in Sociology, No.132, Greenwood Press, Westport (Connecticut), London, pp.ix, 257.
Ghosal, A. edited (1980), Applied Cybernetics and Planning, South Asian Publishers, New Delhi, pp.xvi, 299.
Hanika, F. de P., Tomlinson Rolfe and Trappl Robert edited (1982), Structure and Dynamics of Socio-Economic Systems: Cybernetics in Organisation and Management, Engineering Systems Methodology, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, Washington; (Indian Statistical Institute Library call no. 003.5P964, retrieved from http://library.isical.ac.in/cgi-bin/koha/opac-detail.pl?biblionumber=451&query_desc=au%3A%22Trappl%20Robert%22%20and%20se%3AProgress%20in%20Cybernetics%20and%20Systems%20Research).
Harries-Jones, Peter (1988), “The Self-Organizing Polity: An Epistemological Analysis of Political Life DobuzinskisLaurentBoulder: Westview Press, 1987”, Canadian Journal of Political Science, Vol.21, No.2, June 1988, pp.223.
Hipel, Keith William edited (2009), Conflict Resolution (Volumes I & II), Encyclopedia of Life Support Systems, United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization in partnership with Encyclopedia of Life Support Systems, EOLSS Publishing Co. Ltd., Oxford (U. K.), pp.352 & 447.
Humprecht, Edda (2016), Shaping Online News Performance, Palgrave Macmillan (a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited), U. K., pp.ix, 194.
Johannessen, Jon-Arild and Arnulf Hauan (1994), “Communication—A systems theoretical point of view (third-order cybernetics)”, Systemic Practice and Action Research, Vol.7, No.1, February 1994, pp.63-73.
Knight, Douglas E., Huntington W. Curtis and Lawrence J. Fogel (1971), Cybernetics, Simulation, and Conflict Resolution: Proceedings of the Third Annual Symposium of the American Society for Cybernetics, Spartan Books, pp.249 retrieved from https://books.google.co.in/books/about/Cybernetics_simulation_and_conflict_reso.html?id=YH2xAAAAIAAJ&redir_esc=y.
Kriesi, Hanspeter edited (2012), Political Communication in Direct Democratic Campaigns, Palgrave Macmillan (a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited), U. K., pp.xvii, 265.
Kriesi, Hanspeter, D. Bochsler, J. Matthes, S. Lavenex, M.Bühlmann and F. Esser (2013), Democracy in the Age of Globalization and Mediatization, Palgrave Macmillan (a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited), U. K., pp.xiii, 250.
Laszlo, Ervin (1984), “Cybernetics in an Evolving Social System”, Kybernetes, Vol.13, No.3, pp.141-145.
Lent, Bogdan (2013), Cybernetic Approach to Project Management, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelburg, New York, Dordrecht, London, pp.xxvi, 430.
Leonard, Allenna (2006), “Momentum and control: a dynamic of democracy”, Kybernetes, Vol.35, No.1/2, pp.76–89.
Malik, Fredmund (2016) and Jutta Scherer (Translator), Strategy for Managing Complex Systems: A Contribution to Management Cybernetics for Evolutionary Systems, University of Chicago Press, 15 September, 2016.
McClelland, Kent A. and Thomas J. Fararo edited (2006), Purpose, Meaning and Action: Control System Theories in Sociology, Palgrave Macmillan, New York NY, ISBN 9781403967985.
Medina, Eden (2006), “Designing Freedom, Regulating a Nation: Socialist Cybernetics in Allende’s Chile”, Journal of Latin American Studies, Vol. 38, August 2006, pp.571–606.
Medina, Eden (2011), Cybernetic Revolutionaries: Technologies and Politics in Allende’s Chile, The Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, London.
Morgan, Gareth (2006), The Images of Organizations, Sage Publications, Inc., Thousand Oaks (California), London and New Delhi 110017, pp.xv, 504.
Müller, Lisa (2014a), Comparing Mass Media in Established Democracies: Patterns of Media Performance, Palgrave Macmillan (a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited), U. K., pp.viii, 270, retrieved from http://www.palgraveconnect.com/pc/doifinder/view/10.1057/9781137391384.0001.
Müller, Lisa (2014b), “The impact of the mass media on the quality of democracy within a state remains a much overlooked area of study”, Eurocrisis in the Press, retrieved from http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/eurocrisispress/2014/12/10/the-impact-of-the-mass-media-on-the-quality-of-democracy-within-a-state-remains-a-much-overlooked-area-of-study/.
Novikov, Dimitry A. (2016), Cybernetics: From Past to Future, Studies in Systems, Decision and Control 47, Springer International Publishing Switzerland, p.13.
Piotrowski, Robert (2012), “Between Plato and Wiener: Philosophical cybernetics in the 17th Century”, Studies in Logic, Grammar and Rhetoric, Vol.41, No.28, pp.63–71.
Praveen, Ankitha (2014), “Role of Media in Democracy and Good Governance”, Academike, July 21, 2014, Lawctopus’ Law Journal + Knowledge Center (ISSN: 2349-9796), retrieved from http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/role-media-democracy-good-governance/.
Radice, Henry (2016), “Democracy between Compromise and Control”, Eurocrisis in the Press, retrieved from http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/eurocrisispress/2016/10/20/democracy-between-compromise-and-control/.
Ramsbotham, Oliver, Hugh Miall and Tom Woodhouse (2011), Contemporary Conflict Resolution, 3rd Edition, Polity Press, Cambridge (U. K.), © Ramsbotham, Tom Woodhouse and Hugh Miall.
Rhodes, R. A. W. and Paul’t Hart edited (2014), The Oxford Handbook of Political Leadership, Oxford Handbooks Online, Retrieved from http://www.oxfordhandbooks.com/view/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199653881.001.0001/oxfordhb-9780199653881.
Richards, Larry (1999), “1987 ASC Compilation of Cybernetics Definitions”, Applying the Science of Context, Home of the American Society for Cybernetics, retrieved from http://asc-cybernetics.org/?s=definition+of+cybernetics.
Tumbull, Shann (1994), “Stakeholder Democracy: Redesigning the governance of firms and bureaucracies”, The Journal of Socio-Economics, Vol.23, No.3, Autumn 1994, pp.321-360.
Tzetzes, John (12th century AD), Book of Histories (Chiliades) 2, pp.129-130, Translated by Francis R. Walton, retrieved from https://www.math.nyu.edu/~crorres/Archimedes/Lever/LeverQuotes.html.
Vedel, Thierry (2006), “The Idea of Electronic Democracy: Origins, Visions and Questions”, Parliamentary Affairs, Vol.59, No.2, pp.226-235.
Wiener, Norbert (1948), Cybernetics; or, Control and communication in the animal and the machine, 2nd Edition (1961), The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Copyright © 1948 and 1961 by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, pp.xv, 219.
Wiener, Norbert (1950), The Human Use of Human Beings; Cybernetics and Society, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston.
Winner, Langdon (1969), “Cybernetics and Political Language”, Berkeley Journal of Sociology, Vol.14, pp.1-17.
Yolles, Maurice (2003), “The political cybernetics of organisations”, Kybernetes, Vol.32, Nos.9/10, pp.1253 – 1282.
Zannetos, Zenon Soteriou and Jarrod W. Wilcox (2015), The Management Process, Management Information and Control Systems, and Cybernetics, 2015 Edition, available from 29 September 2015 (the original edition was manually typed and published as a working paper in Alfred P. Sloan School of Management of Massachusetts Institute of Technology at Cambridge, in August 1969).
Zaraté, Pascale, G. Camilleri, D. Kamissoko and F. Amblard edited (2014), Group Decision and Negotiation 2014 (GDN 2014): Proceedings of the Joint International Conference of the INFORMS GDN Section and the EURO Working Group on DSS, Toulouse University, ISBN 978-2-917490-27-3, retrieved from http://oatao.univ-toulouse.fr/11886/.
Zhou, MengChu, Han-Xiong Li and Margot Weijnen edited (2015), Contemporary Issues in Systems Science and Engineering, IEEE Press Series on Systems Science and Engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey, © The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc., retrieved from https://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=yiHPBwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR1&dq=Contemporary+Issues+in+Systems+Science+and+Engineering&ots=fFAQmoKAsm&sig=zAt4dENcC-mRaiHiP-RMV3Vl4Lg#v=onepage&q=Contemporary%20Issues%20in%20Systems%20Science%20and%20Engineering&f=false
►●◄
100zl bez depozytu za rejestracje gry kasynowe za darmo bez rejestracjibook of ra online100 darmowych spinow bez depozytu
https://www.indiegogo.com/en/profile/promocodefor1xbet2026#/overview
My brother suggested I might like this web site.
He was entirely right. This post actually made my day. You cann’t imagine just how much time I had spent for this info!
Thanks!
Howdy I am so excited I found your blog page, I really found you by mistake, while I
was researching on Askjeeve for something else, Regardless
I am here now and would just like to say many thanks for a fantastic
post and a all round entertaining blog (I also love the theme/design),
I don’t have time to look over it all at the minute but I
have book-marked it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do
keep up the awesome jo.
ну не знаю как кому, а мне такие сюрпризы нравятся!!!! ))))
1win официальный сайт, 1win-kdh1.cam предлагает широкий выбор игр и проектов для пользователей. С легким интерфейсом и интуитивно понятной навигацией, каждый найдет то, что ему подходит. Присоединяйтесь к 1win и испытайте возможности заработка!
Самое важное сегодня: https://perfumerio.ru/s/francis-kurkdjian-floralia/
Darmowe spiny bez depozytu 2026 ruletka online w polscewypЕ‚aty total casinofree spiny za rejestracje bez depozytu
If you’re searching for the best online casino, https://tk-servicing.com/online-casino-uae-real-money-play-and-win-today/ adventure, it’s crucial to look at various factors. Bonuses can enhance your gameplay, while service is essential for a smooth experience. Take your time to choose wisely!
Ваша фраза блестяща
Discover the fun of the BC Game Gambling Platform, https://daekindojp.com/index.php/2026/07/06/bc-game-link-for-indonesian-players-discover-the/, where players can test their skills on various innovative games. Join now and explore an extraordinary gaming journey!
人形 エロwith one whitetooth evilly protruding from its steel-like lip A rumpled Chinesejacket of black cotton funereally invested him,with wide blacktrowsers of the same dark stuff.
An impressive share! I’ve just forwarded this onto a co-worker who had been doing
a little research on this. And he in fact bought me breakfast because I discovered it for him…
lol. So let me reword this…. Thanks for the meal!!
But yeah, thanks for spending some time to discuss this topic here
on your website.
Я думаю, что Вы ошибаетесь. Предлагаю это обсудить. Пишите мне в PM.
booi казино, https://gamerealla.ru/ru/ предлагает уникальный опыт в мире азартных игр. Игроки могут наслаждаться многими играми и шансами на выигрыш. Современный интерфейс делает выбор игр удобным. Не упустите шанс выиграть в booi казино!
https://talkmarkets.com/profile/xbet-bonus-260721-152354
The conclusions felt earned rather than tacked on at the end like an afterthought, and a look at trustconverge kept that careful structure going, you can tell when a writer has thought about the shape of their post versus just letting it ramble out and hoping for the best at the end which most do.
Can you tell us more about this? I’d care to find out some additional information.
It’s perfect time to make some plans for the
future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you
some interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you can write next articles referring to this article.
I wish to read even more things about it!
Najlepsze nowe kasyna online legalne kasyna onlinespin city no deposit bonusblackjack online table
poker légal suisse
Also visit my homepage :: bonus de 25 euros casino en ligne [https://snippets.gonfalon.org]
オナホ フィギュアHe called it the Sleet,s crow,
人形 エロand though from every eye,like arrow the eagerglances shot,
ラブドール おすすめbecause it is by such pictures only,when at all well done,
Najlepsze nowe kasyna online w jakich godzinach przychodzД… przelewysalon gier miedzyzdroje22bet bonus za rejestracjД™
https://www.colpozoom.ru/forum/messages/forum1/topic129/message134/?result=new#message134
Наша лучшая подборка: https://russkoitalslovar.ru/%D0%BF%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BD%D1%8F%D1%82%D1%8C%D1%81%D1%8F
Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed!
Extremely helpful information particularly the last part :
) I care for such info a lot. I was looking for this certain info for a very long time.
Thank you and good luck.
https://www.designspiration.com/millionwaves1/saves/
Я знаю, что надо сделать )))
П„Ої ОєО±О»ПЌП„ОµПЃОї online ОєО±О¶ОЇОЅОї, https://claudiodxn.com/online-casino-436026067/ ПЂПЃОїПѓП†ОПЃОµО№ ОґО№О±ПѓОєОµОґО±ПѓП„О№ОєО¬ ПЂО±О№П‡ОЅОЇОґО№О± ОјОµ П†ОїОІОµПЃОП‚ О±ПЂОїОґПЊПѓОµО№П‚. ОџО№ О»О¬П„ПЃОµО№П‚ ОјПЂОїПЃОїПЌОЅ ОЅО± О±ПЂОїО»О±ПЌПѓОїП…ОЅ П„О± ОєО±О»ПЌП„ОµПЃО± П…ПЂОїОґОїП‡ОП‚ ОєО±О№ ПЂПЃОїПЉПЊОЅП„О± live. ОњОµ О±ОѕО№ПЊПЂО№ПѓП„ОµП‚ ПѓП…ОЅО±О»О»О±ОіОП‚ ОєО±О№ ОєО±П„О±ПЂО»О·ОєП„О№ОєО¬ ОјПЂПЊОЅОїП…П‚, О· ОµОјПЂОµО№ПЃОЇО± ОµОЇОЅО±О№ О±ОЅОµОѕОЇП„О·О»О·. О•ПЂО№О»ООіОїОЅП„О±П‚ П„Ої ОєО±О»ПЌП„ОµПЃОї online ОєО±О¶ОЇОЅОї, О· ОґО№О±ПѓОєООґО±ПѓО· ОµОЇОЅО±О№ ПѓП…ОЅОП‡ОµО№О±.
singapore vape shop Premium Vape Store Singapore
SG Vape Delivery Shop is a reliable vape supplier in Singapore, offering genuine vape products for every type of user. Our shop does not sell K Pods, selling only authentic vape products.
Customers can browse a wide collection of disposable vapes from trusted manufacturers including Elf Bar, Vapetape, Lana, RELX, and ONEM. All vape products is carefully chosen for quality, performance, and reliability.
Customer favorites include Lana Ultra 2 16000 Puffs, RELX Infinity Pod, Elf Bar Ice King Pro 45000 Puffs, Lana Pen Plus 9000 Puffs, and ONEM Pod 15000 Puffs. These vape devices deliver excellent flavor, reliable battery life, and consistent vapor production.
The latest arrivals include Vapetape Engage, Elf Bar Ice King Pro 45000 Puffs, Lana Pix 20000 Puffs, ONEM Pod 15000 Puffs, RELX Creator 22000 Puffs, and Elf Bar Raya S1 15000 Puffs. Popular devices are available with promotional prices.
Vapetape Engage provides a modern refillable pod experience. Designed for both beginners and experienced users, it combines strong battery performance, smooth airflow, and excellent flavor.
Customer reviews consistently praise friendly customer support and reliable door-to-door delivery. Many customers prefer SGVapeDeliveryShop because of its dependable service, product selection, and competitive pricing.
Bulk orders are also supported. New resellers can purchase 50 or more products at competitive reseller rates. Bulk purchase options help businesses to expand their inventory.
SGVapeDeliveryShop also publishes educational blog articles covering topics such as vape ingredients and local vaping information. These articles answer common vaping questions.
Buying vape products is easy for every customer. Complete your order online and have authentic vape products delivered directly to your door. SGVapeDeliveryShop focuses on delivering quality vaping solutions with reliable delivery and trusted products.
What’s up everyone, it’s my first pay a visit at this web page, and
post is truly fruitful in favor of me, keep up posting such articles.
roulette bonus de 500 euros casino en ligne ligne namur
Najlepsze nowe kasyna online fairspin casino no deposit bonusjakie najlepsze kasyno onlinelegalne gry hazardowe
https://2cast.com/
First off I want to say superb blog! I had a quick question which I’d like to ask
if you don’t mind. I was interested to find out
how you center yourself and clear your thoughts before writing.
I have had trouble clearing my mind in getting my ideas out there.
I do enjoy writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are wasted simply just
trying to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations
or tips? Thank you!
http://id.kaywa.com/xbetfreebet11
in clothes ofmy own size: had soon passed through the house,where Bradshaw staredand drew back at seeing Mr.高級 ダッチワイフ
Its like you learn my thoughts! You seem to know a lot about this, like you wrote the e-book
in it or something. I think that you just can do with a
few p.c. to force the message house a little bit, however other than that, this is magnificent blog.
A fantastic read. I’ll definitely be back.
10 euros offert casino 40 euros dépôt minimum
(Roubenkapaseky.cz)
Только лучшие материалы: https://frenchspeak.ru/%D0%BE%D0%BF%D1%83%D1%85%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%8C
automatenspiele casino
Feel free to surf to my blog post Free Bet Blackjack Um Geld Spielen
Casino Online Polska planet 7 casinobook of dead slotbonus bez obrotu
Мріяли в’їхати у повністю готову для комфортного проживання квартиру без необхідності доробляти дрібні деталі самостійно. Комплексний ремонт квартири Київ під ключ https://remont-kvartiry.in.ua/ від фахівців даного ресурсу виправдав абсолютно всі наші очікування і навіть перевершив їх. Хлопці здали об’єкт точно у встановлений договором термін та залишили після себе ідеальну чистоту.
bekannte casino anmelden und freispiel bekommen
spiele
Best casino
https://slotsgemkasino.com/
У сучасному ритмі життя важливо мати під рукою надійне джерело інформації про свій рідний край. Читати новини Суми https://freedom.sumy.ua/ саме тут — це найкращий вибір для тих, хто цінує свій час та правду. Дякую розробникам за якісний сайт, а авторам — за чудову щоденну роботу.
If you are going for finest contents like me, simply go to see this web site everyday for the
reason that it presents feature contents, thanks
my web page Click Here!
Słuchajcie, mam intrygującą spostrzeżenie w kwestii hazardu.
Wiadomo, że każdy liczy na konkretny zysk, choć po czasie staje się jasne, że kluczem jest dyscyplina.
Zdarza się, że analizując spinmama casino bonus da się znaleźć całkiem kursy, o których
sporo obstawiających po prostu zapomina.
Moim zdaniem największym wyzwaniem jest tendencja do błyskawicznego odrobienia strat,
co przeważnie prowadzi do kolejnymi kłopotami.
Zupełnie odmiennie prezentuje nastawienie gracza, kto traktuje zakłady jako sposób rozrywki, a nie metodę na
opłacenie zobowiązań. A czy wy też doświadczyliście coś podobnego, że spokojna analiza uchroniła was przed
wielkim minusem? A jakie metody kontroli kapitałem stosujecie za najlepsze?
Могу предложить зайти на сайт, с огромным количеством информации по интересующей Вас теме.
Playing at betting sites outside GamStop offers punters a chance to enjoy varied games without limitations. These platforms provide more opportunities for earning cash and adventure. With lavish bonuses and offers, the experience becomes even more attractive. Exploring these choices ensures a unique gaming journey while enjoying casino outside GamStop, https://solholidayrentals.com/?p=52170. Don’t miss your chance to experience this vibrant environment of online gaming!
Best casino
https://realscasino.com/
Online Casinos UAE, https://tarneitcentralmedical.com.au/exploring-arabic-online-casinos-a-guide-to-the-best-gaming-experience/ provide a thrilling experience for bettors. With a range of games, players can enjoy table games. Incentives are also presented, improving the gaming experience and enticing new users.
In my experience, exploring current games is much resembles studying a intricate system than merely clicking the
key. I’ve always found how understanding the mechanics stays absolutely essential before diving
in, and this stays just the reason using this fishin frenzy demo free acts as quite a wise play towards dodge pointless shocks later on the path.
It’s fascinating the way special rounds might totally
shift the perspective of volatility, yet the game nevertheless comes back to maintaining solid limits.
Could any of you really noticed a significant shift in win speeds across those
different reel setups? I am really curious whether those advanced versions stand actually worth your added
effort, therefore please drop some ideas below for begin a
discussion going!
Darmowe spiny bez depozytu 2026 casino online gameskasyno online nowebonus bez depozytu grudzien 2026
spiel in online casino bonus auszahlen lassen altenkirchen
https://paper.wf/1xbetfreee/1xbet-2026-promo-code-1xrun200-bonus-eu130
slots Bonus D’accueil De Casinos En Ligne (Hennekens.Net) ligne gagne
https://murav.ru/forum/messages/forum1/topic382/message235/?result=new#message235
https://webhitlist.com/forum/topics/comment-choisir-parmi-les-meilleures-offres-de-casino
Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks! https://www.binance.bh/futures/ref?code=IXBIAFVY
п»їWyplacalne kasyna internetowe automaty do gry krzyЕјГіwkawspГіЕ‚czynnik rtp total casinorapid casino bonus bez depozytu
Unquestionably believe that which you stated. Your favorite reason seemed to be on the web the simplest thing to be aware of.
I say to you, I definitely get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly do not know about.
You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole
thing without having side-effects , people could take a signal.
Will probably be back to get more. Thanks
aslı
http://learndash.aula.edu.pe/miembros/xbetbonus111/
снять виллу в Анталии Долгосрочная аренда жилья в Анталии — популярный выбор среди экспатов, решивших переехать в теплый климат. Наслаждайтесь морем, солнцем и дружелюбной атмосферой круглый год.
https://www.popdaily.com.tw/user/547681
online casino 10 euro Einzahlung neosurf (ibanretegi.com) ab 1
euro muchbetter
https://gomel-by.actieforum.com/t353-melbet-%D0%9F%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B4-%D0%9D%D0%B0-%D0%91%D0%B5%D1%81%D0%BF%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%BD%D1%83%D1%8E-%D0%A1%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%BA%D1%83-2026-bnb777-%D0%91%D0%BE%D0%BD%D1%83%D1%81-25000#533
paypal casino mit 80 freispielen ohne einzahlung erfahrungen
https://www.band.us/band/103636159/post
https://4dkp.forum24.ru/?1-18-0-00009316-000-0-0-1784545345
http://www.bisound.com/forum/showthread.php?p=3308344#post3308344
https://pad.stuve.uni-ulm.de/s/ouYMzvepr
https://sinangagstation.com/find-the-best-card-playing-incentive-and-welcome-volunteer-for-your-next-report-registration/
Stands apart from similar pages by actually being useful, that is high praise these days, and a look at bondedlegacyline kept that standard going, you can tell when a site is built around the reader versus around metrics and this one clearly belongs to the first category for sure based on what I read.
301 Moved Permanently https://35teremok.ru/kombo-city-holder-na-22-marta/ – 301 Moved Permanently…
Darmowe spiny bez depozytu 2026 maszyny do gry na pieniądzesizzling hot darmowe gryjak grać w jackpot
https://sydney-decamp-s-solutions.mn.co/posts/104851712?utm_source=manual
yo ngl shuffle is pretty decent tbh, like the site runs smooth fr no lag or anything. imo the games r decent selection wise lowkey better than what i expected lol шафл казино
casino slotspiele echtgeld (https://Www.Arthead.sk/) ohne lugas
lastschrift
301 Moved Permanently https://grow-report.ru/poshagovoe-rukovodstvo-po-podboru-shtor-dlya-gostinoy-s-raschetami-tkani-sveta-i- – More info>>>
Best casino
https://robycasino-de.com/
Best casino
https://bassbet-kasino.com/
Best casino
https://trinocasino-de.com/
casinos ohne geld spielen
my website – Casino 10 Euro Cashtocode, http://Net.Avlentertainment.Com,
Darmowe spiny bez depozytu 2026 22 bet casinolegalne kasyno polskieautomaty do gier wrocЕ‚aw
poker légal suisse
Here is my web site; délai retrait casino mastercard
https://mymaleextrareview.com/bonus-de-casino-en-ligne-astuces-pour-maximiser-vos-recompenses/
Buongiorno ragazzi, ho di recente qualche curiosa esperienza giocando sulle piattaforme del settore.
Onestamente, credo che una gestione del budget rimanga davvero il punto più fondamentale per si prova di scommettere.
Molti utenti spesso sbagliano di non fissare dei paletti di spesa, ritrovandosi
poi con nervosismo evitabili. Ho visto che utilizzando
alf casinos molti
possono trovare informazioni molto utili circa ottimizzare il approccio al gioco.
Inoltre, non è bisogna nemmeno scordare che la componente di pura sorte
rimane sempre presente, quindi sarebbe meglio avere sempre
una mente lucida. Voi cosa ne dite della nuova ondata di live?
Inoltre, avete già provato questo approccio specifico nelle proprie partite quotidiane?
Sarei parecchio curioso a leggere le vostre opinioni riguardo per scambiare pareri.
Да, верно.
BC Game Online Casino, https://www.canoaclublegnago.it/2026/07/06/maximize-your-winnings-the-ultimate-bc-game-bonus/ offers a delightful experience for players around the globe. With various games and appealing bonuses, it ensures unending entertainment. Join now and discover the fun!
Вы можете перейти на официальный
сайт 1 Vin с этой странице или скачать игровой клиент на
Айфон и Android.
To be fair, I been spending some more time these days looking into the
ways various digital gaming truly operate these promotional initiatives.
A observation which keeps surprising my attention is
simply how significantly a lot varied the promotions have become when compared to a
several months ago. This seems like each casino perpetually within the tough race intended to
get the attention regarding regular players, plus that usually leads towards some actually innovative
casino incentive layouts that don’t really need a big upfront investment.
A main take is which not every promotion truly quite simple as it at first seems.
I’ve observed that the best value frequently comes once a player
have some time in order to really study the policies before diving
headfirst into the session. Particularly, when I use a spingranny bonus code via that source,
I ensure sure that I understand the betting requirement rather
what selected games actually contribute to the goal. There, using spin granny bonus code may actually
be the handy shortcut concerning finding that most trusted info lacking hunting for hours.
I’ve also feel that users that remain consistent usually
see more reward perks that really increase up across this full term.
Do you ever felt some trouble regarding triggering those incentives?
Do anyone reckon that some current direction involving fewer yet
more frequent rewards is truly superior for most regular users there?
Наша цель — быстро решать ваши
проблемы и обеспечить комфортное и приятное времяпрепровождение в Azino казино.
This blog post is excellent, probably because of how well the subject was developed. I like some of the comments too though I could prefer we all stay on the subject in order add value to the subject!
100zl bez depozytu za rejestracje lotto gra przez internetautomaty bez rejestracjinovomatic slots online free
xiqevphxmgniggouhqensdpnlrtmpx
tnppddujtgtxqejwnvovoxfzmskmjt
я чуть не захлебнулся))))
Når man leder efter gambling sider uden dansk identifikation, er der flere muligheder at vælge imellem. casinoer uden nemid, https://quick2dry.skylinelisting.com/casino-sider-uden-rofus-din-guide-til/ giver brugerne mulighed for at nyde uden problemer. Det er vigtigt at undersøge sikkerhed og regulering inden du tilmelder dig.
Casino Online Polska maszyny hazardowe online za pieniД…dzedarmowe gry hazardowe automaty bez rejestracji sizzling hotbook of dead slot
https://beteiligung.einbeck.de/profile/1xbtcode2027/
Переглядаючи останні трансферні чутки, я завжди шукаю підтвердження лише на перевірених спортивних ресурсах. Український футбол football.org.ua зараз переживає непрості часи, але такі змістовні публікації додають оптимізму всім вболівальникам. Продовжуйте й надалі тішити нас якісними оглядами та оперативними оперативними новинами зі стадіонів.
https://trusting-clove-164.notion.site/Promo-Code-for-1xBet-2027-1X200KING-Official-Bonus-3a438da9297b8072aebee7edc4e3a013?pvs=73
Багато інформаційних джерел зараз зловживають клікбейтом, що сильно знижує довіру до їхніх матеріалів. Проте новини України skydive.in.ua на цьому ресурсі завжди подаються стримано, об’єктивно та без зайвої паніки. Це свідчить про високий професіоналізм та повагу до свого читача.
посмотреть в этом разделе https://slon11-cc.com
Hi there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing several weeks of hard work due to no back up. Do you have any solutions to protect against hackers?
sg vape
SGVape Hub is recognized as a trusted vape shop for high-quality vape devices in Singapore. Our shop offers fast same day delivery across Singapore with cash on delivery, making customers a hassle-free shopping experience.
Explore trusted brands such as Vapetape, Lana, RELX, ELFBAR, Snowwolf, ONEM, and SP2. Every product is selected to offer smooth vaping, great flavor, and dependable reliability.
SGVape Hub only sells clean nicotine vape devices. Illegal vape products are excluded and no prohibited ingredients are offered, giving customers confidence with every purchase.
Enjoy additional savings when ordering multiple products. Buy 6 or more items and get $5 OFF. Orders of 11 pieces or more receive $10 OFF. Free delivery is available for orders exceeding $300.
Top-selling products include Vapetape Offgrid Reload, Vapetape Engage, Lana Ultra II 16000 Puffs, Lana Touch 32000 Puffs, Lana Pen Plus 9000 Puffs, ELFBAR Ice King 40000 Puffs, Snowwolf 16000 Puffs, RELX Creator 22000 Puffs, and Vapetape Offgrid 12000 Puffs. These models offer long-lasting performance, consistent performance, and great flavor.
A featured new product is the VAPETAPE ENGAGE open pod system. It features a powerful 2600mAh battery, adjustable wattage up to 50W, and multiple cartridge choices. Choose the 0.4? cartridge for larger clouds, or use the 0.6? pod for enhanced flavor.
The store also offers Offgrid replacement cartridges, including ONEM 15K puffs and Vapetape Offgrid Reload cartridges. These alternatives offer excellent compatibility while offering better value.
Fast delivery, premium vape brands, great pricing, and strict quality standards continue to make SGVape Hub a trusted choice for Singapore vape customers.
Читать расширенную версию: https://rysadba.ru/item/dom-77/
At this moment I am going to do my breakfast, afterward having my breakfast coming again to
read further news.
Finding the best online casinos Greece, https://www.arackiralama.online/discover-the-best-online-casinos-in-greece-1040329781/ can be a thrilling experience. Many platforms offer entertaining games. Players can experience an extensive range of options, from slots to table games. Incentives are often available to increase gameplay, ensuring maximum entertainment. Always review the certification to ensure safety. Engaging with the best online casinos Greece will lead to unforgettable gaming moments!
Подробнее здесь https://slonz11.cc
Casino Online Polska gra koЕ‚o fortunytop 10 kasyn onlinespin city bonus za rejestracjД™
Well done! Keep up this quality!
нетслов ето зачот
Online casinos provide exciting casino experiences for players looking for fun. For those seeking options, casino outside GamStop, https://shaneworks.com/exploring-the-sites-not-on-gamstop/ offers a chance to play without restrictions. Enjoy a wide range of games in a safe environment.
I enjoyed reading this article. A well-designed customer survey benefits both the company and the
customer by creating a better experience over time.
100zl bez depozytu za rejestracje energy casino 38gra o pieniД…dzefontan casino bonus bez depozytu kod
жилье посуточно в Анталии Выгодная аренда посуточно в Анталии сэкономит ваш бюджет для экскурсий, шопинга и гастрономических открытий. Открывайте для себя новые грани отдыха без лишних переплат.
гг..неплохо
Finding a reliable wagering platform can be challenging. The non GamStop UK casino, https://funtime.ma/discover-uk-non-gamstop-sites-for-an-unrestricted-betting-experience/ options provide enthusiasts with a chance to enjoy risk-free gaming without undue restrictions. These casinos often offer varied games and lucrative bonuses, ensuring an engaging experience.
Обучающие курсы ИИ Python + AI дает вам мощный фундамент для разработки интеллектуальных систем с нуля. Наши курсы включают много практики, чтобы вы сразу применяли знания в деле.
Casino Online Polska najbliЕјszy punkt lotto otwarte terazgry na automatach apolloetoto bonus bez depozytu
Looking through the archives suggests this site has been doing this for a while at this level, and a look at unitypillar confirmed the long term consistency, sites that have maintained quality across years rather than just a recent stretch are sites with serious editorial discipline and this one has clearly been at it for a while.
whoah this weblog is great i really like studying your articles. Stay up the great work! You already know, lots of persons are looking round for this information, you can aid them greatly.
It’s perfect time to make a few plans for the longer
term and it’s time to be happy. I’ve read this
post and if I may just I want to recommend you some fascinating issues or tips.
Perhaps you could write next articles regarding this
article. I wish to read more things about it!
Casino Online Polska black jack punktacjasalon gier czestochowaspinbounty no deposit bonus
With havin so much content and articles do you ever run into any issues of plagorism or
copyright infringement? My website has a lot of exclusive content I’ve either authored myself or
outsourced but it looks like a lot of it is popping it up all over the
internet without my permission. Do you know any ways to help stop
content from being stolen? I’d genuinely appreciate it.
Это хорошая идея.
danske spil uden nemid, https://codematrixtech.com/oplev-de-bedste-casinoer-uden-om-rufus-5/ tilbyder en spændende mulighed for spillere, der ønsker at spille online uden at bruge en identitetstjeneste. Da kan brugere let deltage i forskellige spil. Sådan en tilgang muliggør en frisk måde at være med på uden besvær. Danske spil uden nemid vokser at fascinere spillere fra hele landet.
This paragraph will help the internet people for building up new
weblog or even a weblog from start to end.
Discovering the best online casinos Greece, https://itsallfreeonline.com/exploring-foreign-online-casinos-in-greece-1032689828/ offers is an exciting journey for players seeking thrilling experiences. These sites provide multiple games and enticing bonuses. Enjoying interactive experiences adds to the fun. Explore safe payment methods for smooth transactions. Join the vibrant community of gamblers and immerse yourself in the fun of gaming online!
Took me time to read the material, but I truly loved the article. It turned out to be very useful to me.
Замечательно, очень полезная штука
1win официальный вход, 1win зеркало сайта позволяет игрокам быстро получать доступ к своему аккаунту. Это стандарт безопасности придает больше уверенность пользователям. На портале представлены широкие возможности для ставок.
asli
Najlepsze nowe kasyna online poker zasady texaslegalne kasyno online holandiatotal casino ruletka
Читать далее: https://aromatmasla.ru
Прелестное сообщение
If you’re looking for reliable gaming options, safe non GamStop casinos, https://photobanao.com/2026/07/06/explore-casino-options-without-gamstop-restrictions/ offer top-notch experiences. These platforms ensure a variety of games without the restrictions of GamStop. Players can relax with their favorite games freely.
Конечно. Я присоединяюсь ко всему выше сказанному. Давайте обсудим этот вопрос. Здесь или в PM.
1win casino, https://1win-k8m34.top/ предлагает выбор ассортимент игр, чтобы порадовать каждого игрока. У нас можно найти новейшие игры и увлекательные бонусы. Начните приключение в 1win casino и погружайтесь азартом!
Najlepsze nowe kasyna online alf casino bonus bez depozytutotal casino demo jokerpromocje na urodziny
Best casino
https://casinovacasino-de.com/
Best casino
https://gxbet-de.com/
Быстрый ответ, признак сообразительности 😉
бутик парфюмерии, https://slovarsbor.ru/c/3-%D1%84%D1%83/ — место, где каждый найдет аромат, способный подчеркнуть его индивидуальность. Обширный выбор новинки и уникальные варианты поразят даже самых взыскательных ценителей. Комфортная атмосфера и профессиональные консультанты помогут сделать оптимальный выбор. Не упустите шанс посетить наш бутик парфюмерии!
Это сообщение, бесподобно ))), мне очень нравится 🙂
Engaging in a non UKGC licensed casino, https://miratechco.com/non-uk-regulated-casinos-accepting-uk-players-a-comprehensive-guide-1012940328/ offers unique opportunities for players seeking diverse gaming experiences. These casinos often feature a wider selection of games, appealing to those who seek excitement. On the downside, it’s essential to be cautious since safeguards might be weaker. Always do your homework before playing.
A human rights lawyer, https://www.tuttifrutti.it/international-human-rights-litigation-understanding-the-role-of-the-echr/ supports the rights of individuals facing injustice. They endeavor to ensure equality in legal systems. Through court cases, they combat oppression and empower marginalized communities.
100zl bez depozytu za rejestracje gg bet kod promocyjny bez depozytukasyno bonus za rejestracjД™ 2026total casino w co najlepiej grac
It’s remarkable designed for me to have a web site, which is helpful in favor of my knowledge.
thanks admin
I always emailed this weblog post page to all my friends, for the reason that if like
to read it after that my contacts will too.
100zl bez depozytu za rejestracje hotslots kod promocyjnynajpopularniejsze kasyno onlineloki casino bonus bez depozytu
Это ценный ответ
1win официальный вход, https://1win-5rfc1.cfd/ предоставляет пользователям простой и удобный доступ к ставкам. В указанном сайте можно найти разнообразные варианты ставок. Подключайтесь к досугам играм уже сейчас.
Огромное спасибо, как я могу Вас отблагодарить?
I dag kan du finde mange online spillesteder, der tilbyder sjov uden behov for identifikation. Et af de bedste valg er casino uden mitid, https://pornx.vicetemple.io/udenlandske-casinoer-uden-nemid-hvorfor-og-hvordan/, hvor du kan unde dine yndlingsspil uden besvær. Derfor er det smart prøve det i dag?
куль)))
1win официальный сайт, официальный 1вин предлагает игрокам широкий выбор азартных игр и спортивных событий. Пользователи могут наслаждаться внушительными коэффициентами и удобным интерфейсом. Личный кабинет позволяет легко управлять счетом и участвовать в акциях.
To be fair, I feel that current wagering has totally changed recently.
One thing I saw is how easy the real-time croupiers make the whole experience feel, especially when you are testing a trusted site like spino gambino to set your bets.
A second point is that fund planning is certainly more key than raw
fortune provided you plan to remain in the play for a while.
Additionally, the mobile performance nowadays
is just fantastic, permitting folks to spin wherever.
However, do you think that virtual casinos will soon supplant the
old-school style we all enjoy? Furthermore, what certain tricks would you recommend for someone
trying to maximize their win rate next time? I’d love to know your views on this subject!
Najlepsze nowe kasyna online automaty hot spotlista kasyn onlinebonus za zaЕ‚oЕјenie konta bukmacher
Искусство драпировки: как сшить шторы, которые говорят о вас http://devchurka.ru/iskusstvo-drapirovki-kak-sshit-shtory-kotorye-govoryat-o-vas/ – Искусство драпировки: как сшить шторы, которые говорят о вас…
Good blog you’ve got here.. It’s hard to find excellent
writing like yours these days. I really appreciate individuals like
you! Take care!!
Балин, вот это да…:(
BC Game Platform, https://smartedgetech.ca/?p=44881 offers an engaging environment for players. With multiple options, users can enjoy fun and exceptional entertainment. Join today and uncover the distinct features and rewards it provides!
sanctions lawyers, https://suriusrepair.com/understanding-sanctions-compliance-best-practices-and-challenges/ provide critical assistance in navigating complex legal frameworks. They support businesses to navigate sanctions, ensuring compliance with national laws. These professionals reduce potential penalties for clients operating in challenging environments.
Best casino
https://newluckycasino1.com/
Best casino
https://piperspin1-casino.com/
Darmowe spiny bez depozytu 2026 casino online za darmokasyno na prawdziwe pieniД…dze sklep playmapy w valorancie
During my morning reading slot this fit perfectly into the routine, and a look at trustalignment extended that perfect fit into the rest of the routine, content that matches the rhythm of how I actually read rather than demanding accommodation from my schedule is content well calibrated to its likely audience and this site has it.
Поздравляю, ваша мысль очень хороша
In the world of online gaming, reliable non GamStop casinos offer players an superior alternative. These platforms provide access to a variety of entertainment, ensuring a pleasant experience. Players can enjoy their favorite games free from restrictions. With fair practices, players can feel confident while playing. Join the community of enthusiasts looking for safe non GamStop casinos, https://www.rptor.pl/discovering-online-gambling-sites-not-on-gamstop/ and explore what these venues have to offer!
I am really impressed along with your writing talents and also with the layout for your
weblog. Is this a paid topic or did you modify it your self?
Anyway stay up the nice high quality writing, it’s uncommon to look a great weblog like
this one today..
концовка предсказуема с самого начала
Элитная парфюмерия, https://slovarsbor.ru/w/%D0%B4%D1%8D/ предлагает уникальные ароматы, созданные мастерами. Использование редких ингредиентов добавляет изысканность. Такой ароматы в особенности ценятся знатоками. Элитная парфюмерия — это ремесло создавать классные композиции.
Искусство текстиля: как шторы меняют атмосферу гостиной | Contipromo.ru https://contipromo.ru/exciting/iskusstvo-tekstilya-kak-shtory-menyayut-atmosferu-gostinoj/ – Contipromo.ru!
Quality content is the key to attract the people
to visit the site, that’s what this website is providing.
Поздравляю, мне кажется это великолепная мысль
1win официальный вход, https://1win-8dmfy.sbs предоставляет игрокам легкий доступ к пространству азартных игр. Открытие счета занимает всего несколько минут. Платформа обеспечивает разнообразный выбор активностей, что создает её известной среди поклонников. Чтобы начать, просто воспользуйтесь 1win официальный вход.
100zl bez depozytu za rejestracje trakt brzeski 85automaty na prawdziwe pieniadzekod promocyjny na darmowe spiny
Я думаю, что Вы не правы. Могу отстоять свою позицию. Пишите мне в PM, обсудим.
In the world of online gambling, various players seek options outside of traditional restrictions. The non GamStop UK casino, https://alquilertitulotransportista.com/discover-new-casinos-not-on-gamstop-for-an-uninterrupted-gaming-experience/ offers a special experience, allowing users to partake in their favorite games without limits. With captivating bonuses and a wide range for entertainment, these platforms lure those looking for flexibility in their gaming experience.
Идея потрясающая, поддерживаю.
1win casino, 1win-g4kau.top предлагает богатый выбор игр, включая лотереи и карточные игры. Регистрация легка. Клиенты могут иметь подарки и вовлекаться в мероприятиях.
согласен но как видиш на тавар есть спрос))
1win официальный сайт, 1win-zln1.cam предлагает широкий выбор пари для ценителей азартных пари. На платформе вы найдете все необходимое для насыщенного досуга.
100zl bez depozytu za rejestracje darmowe spiny za rejestracjД™ nowoЕ›cipolska ruletka czatlemon casino free spins
Wow, that’s what I was searching for, what a data!
existing here at this weblog, thanks admin of this web site.
Попробуйте свои силы в лучших играх на alpha66 online и почувствуйте настоящий азарт прямо сейчас!
Frequent system updates and vigilant oversight help sustain a reliable environment, giving users confidence in data protection.
Appreciate this post. Let me try it out.
Does your blog have a contact page? I’m having trouble locating it but,
I’d like to shoot you an email. I’ve got some suggestions for
your blog you might be interested in hearing.
Either way, great website and I look forward to seeing it grow over time.
aslı
buk clinic
I could not refrain from commenting. Perfectly written!
asli
OFAC lawyers, https://thecannabin.com/understanding-ofac-delisting-navigating-the-sdn-list-removal-process-947681343/ are important in navigating the complexities of sanctions compliance. Their skills helps clients comprehend legal implications, securing compliance with regulations.
Najlepsze nowe kasyna online kasyno online legalnekasyna internetowe legalne w polscedarmowe gry automaty online
I like the helpful information you provide in your articles.
I will bookmark your blog and check again here regularly. I am
quite sure I’ll learn many new stuff right here!
Best of luck for the next!
ist
Darmowe spiny bez depozytu 2026 up bonus kartypolskie internetowe kasynobonus joker za darmo
Hi there! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and tell you I truly
enjoy reading through your blog posts. Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that cover the same subjects?
Thanks a ton!
https://cantilenachoir.ru/
https://pcscoff.ru/club/user/2096/blog/277/
http://saratovturizm.ru/
https://logcla.com/blogs/1708264/%D0%9F%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B4-Melbet-%D0%9D%D0%B0-%D0%A1%D0%B5%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BD%D1%8F-%D0%9F%D1%80%D0%B8-%D0%A0%D0%B5%D0%B3%D0%B8%D1%81%D1%82%D1%80%D0%B0%D1%86%D0%B8%D0%B8-2026-GAME888
Discover aggregated promotions аt Kaizenaire.cοm, Singapore’ѕ leading deals website.
Singaporeans neᴠer mіss a beat when it
comes to deals, thriving іn their city’ѕ atmjosphere as thе
ultimate shopping heaven.
Capturing blockbuster motion pictures аt Cineleisure
іѕ a classic enjoyment selection fօr Singaporeans, аnd remember to stay updated οn Singapore’s
mⲟst recent promotions and shopping deals.
Shopee, а leading shopping system, markets ｅverything
fгom devices to grocery stores, beloved Ьy Singaporeans fߋr its flash sales
and straightforward app.
CapitaLand Investment establishes ɑnd manages buildings sia, cherished bｙ Singaporeans for theіr legendary malls аnd property ɑreas lah.
Scent Bak Kwa grills tender jerky pieces, preferred fοr fragrant, melt-in-mouth festive deals ᴡith.
Aunties recognize lah, Kaizenaire.сom һaѕ thｅ most гecent deals leh.
Ꮮoߋk ɑt my web blog Kaizenaire Promotions
Я ево хачу!!!
1win официальный сайт, https://1win-glt7.buzz предлагает обширный выбор ставок, включая покер. Пользователи могут наслаждаться интуитивно понятным интерфейсом и щедрыми акциями.
Это очень ценное мнение
non GamStop online casino, https://iplusstd.com/item/eventBookingPro/admin/2026/07/06/what-gambling-sites-are-not-a-comprehensive-guide/ provides players with a unique experience that is not bound by the usual restrictions. In these platforms, gamblers can experience a wider range of games, presenting more options than traditional casinos. Players can choose from various exciting games, enjoying flexibility to play without obstacles. Non GamStop online casino confirms a deeper gambling experience for all.
По-моему это уже обсуждалось, воспользуйтесь поиском.
1win официальный вход, https://1win-bu7z1.sbs предоставляет пользователям удобный доступ к азартным играм. Платформа предлагает разнообразный выбор игр и опций. Создание аккаунта проста и удобна, что упрощает начать играть.
Darmowe spiny bez depozytu 2026 fairspin casino no deposit bonusvulkan vegas bonus urodzinowyenergy casino 30
Да, это вразумительный ответ
If you’re looking for excitement with a small initial investment, a minimum deposit casino, http://silverwings.at/unlocking-the-potential-high-paying-casino-2/ is the perfect choice. These venues allow you to dive into thrilling games without breaking the bank. You can discover a variety of table games while keeping your finances in check. Whether you’re a occasional player or just starting, minimum deposit casino options are user-friendly and reachable. So take a chance and gamble your way to huge wins today!
After looking over a number of the blog posts on your
site, I truly like your way of blogging. I book-marked it to my
bookmark site list and will be checking back in the near future.
Take a look at my website too and let me know how you feel.
Вы топик читали?
online social casinos, https://app.24acres.co.in/the-best-social-casinos-where-fun-meets-fortune/ give a unique opportunity for players to relish their favorite games. Such platforms permit users to engage with peers while betting. Explore the fun today!